The most common and most likely answer to this crossword clue is the 16 letter word I DON’T BUY IT which also is the latest solution we found used in New York Times in 2025.
“Seems fishy to me” crossword clue answers
Here's a list of possible crossword answers ranked by the most likely to least likely.
| Answer | Likelyness | Letters |
|---|---|---|
| I DON’T BUY IT | 100 % | 16 |
Why may I-DONT-BUY-IT be the right solution?
"I DON’T BUY IT" is the right solution because it is a common phrase meaning to not believe or trust something, which fits the clue "Seems fishy to me."
Words with a meaning similar to the clue: “Seems fishy to me”
These words may or may not be a possible solution to this crosswords clue.- guess
- think
- methinks
- meseems
- appear
- appears
- believe
- feel
- operate
- seem
- thinks
- impersonal
More crossword clues leading to the same solutions
Here's a few more crossword clues - all leading to the identical solution